WE ARE WEST SEATTLE RESIDENTS CONCERNED ABOUT SOUND TRANSIT’S PROPOSED LIGHT RAIL PLANS

SODO center platform rendering (by author over Google Maps)

Sound Transit Community Panel

Annual Report 28 March 2024 statement

"In the context of evaluation of project alternatives during the planning and environmental review process, the COP often asks staff for assurance that alternatives under consideration would achieve the goals of the System 5 Plans, and explanations of how they would do so. In the case of some of the alternatives introduced in the past year, particularly on the West Seattle and Ballard Link Extensions, staff have been unable to provide such assurance. This will be a matter of ongoing concern to the COP in coming years."

Letters to Sound Transit COP

Kim Schwerzkopf, West Seattle resident, April 10, 2024

Hello from West Seattle, 
I live and play in the West Seattle/ Duwamish Valley area and actively work to build a healthy community for all. 
I was a member of the Sound Transit CAG (Community Advisory Group) and at the end of all of our meetings, it was almost unanimous that there was “no good option” presented. 
All of the routes have negative impacts on ridership experience and the environment. 
The DEIS was inadequate in many ways and options were deemed “unmitigable”. 
We have yet to see any full maps/details of the “Further Studies” routes (eliminate Avalon route and the access and integration for Delridge). 
We are especially concerned about the Duwamish crossing - affecting the water/ soil/ fish and also going through the steep slope, trees and heron colony on Pigeon Point and going over Longfellow Creek where Salmon are returning. 
Also, the “community engagement” is insulting and not inclusive at all. I have spent many days trying to build awareness with communities along Delridge to give them a heads up. We have reached out to the ST team through the years and all responses are performative at best. We deserve real and meaningful engagement. 
We care about our community and feel this whole process has been unjust, the project is not worth all of the damage and displacement. It’s not the right solution for our climate goals. 
We would love to meet and further discuss our concerns.
 

 

Martin Pagel, Columbia City resident, April 10, 2024

Thank you for providing valuable oversight. West Seattle would be much better served by the ebuses which Sound Transit plans to use for STRIDE than by a few light rail stations. In fact transit experience will suffer by forcing most riders to do multiple transfers for a short ride to downtown as I reported on West Seattle Now vs Light Rail – Seattle Transit Blog

So why does Sound Transit prioritize WSLE and delay BLE? The WSLE DEIS only shows daily reduction of 500 cars by 2040, so why do we spend $4 billion on this project, generate 614,000 tons of carbon during construction, and destroy some of the businesses and homes we want to serve?!? Metro has not even yet reestablished all the bus lines which served WS before the pandemic, that would actually increase ridership far more and cost less!

Sound Transit’s keeps touting their outreach efforts but those are merely marketing efforts, they do not listen to concerns of how WSLE will make the ridership experience worse. Transfers at the SODO station and the North/Sound CID will be very cumbersome but Sound Transit prioritizes operational efficiency over ridership experience.

Our region needs a realistic transportation plan that is effective and affordable.

Sound Transit has worked hard to devise the best solution for West Seattle, and it still is a mess. The solution they came up with, which is now going to be in the final DEIS,  will wreck the neighborhood by removing many businesses, housing, and natural areas, and it will not help the transit experience.  Sound Transit failed the DEIS because the benefits of the whole construction are not worth it. In comparison, it should not be built.  The West Seattle light rail extension fails on all three dimensions of sustainability -- environment, economics, and equity. There are better ways to spend public transit dollars for a fraction of the cost. King County Metro using electric buses could make public transit world class throughout the West Seattle peninsula.

We want a say in our future!

Three citizen coalitions, rethinkthelink.orgsmartertransit.org, and Amplify Avalon, have tried and failed to get Sound Transit to talk with us.  Our members have studied local transit and national and international systems.  Some members have spent years on regional environmental issues, including West Seattle’s many unique ecosystems.  We are ALL transit riders.  Some of us are car-free.  Our mission is to help bring smart, equitable, fiscally responsible solutions to our transportation needs.  

We urged the Systems Expansion Board not to advance Resolution R2024-07 on March 14, 2024.  They did, unanimously.

Resolution No. R2024-07 was anticipating a Build Decision.  However, based on the evidence in the Draft EIS, it's easy to see that building a three-station light rail stub line is the wrong decision for West Seattle.  

 The redeployment of Sound Transit light rail funds to enhance the existing bus service to and around the West Seattle Peninsula is more sustainable—environmentally, economically, and with regard to social equity. Taking this different, less expensive, more sustainable approach to High-Capacity Transit to West Seattle is well within Sound Transit's existing authority.

Our concerns for West Seattle will impact the entire region:

1.    70 businesses will be claimed by eminent domain.

2.    500 people will lose their jobs when these businesses close.

3.    Our families will lose Alki Beach Academy – local daycare for +-150 children ages 5 months to 6 years.

4.    Our community will lose one of the few swimming pools in West Seattle where our children learn to swim.

5.    Bulldozing the Deli in Delridge will create a “food desert,” which will create a particularly inequitable situation for the poorer Delridge neighbors.

6.    Jefferson Square businesses  (39, including Safeway and Bartell) and apartments will be demolished. 

7.    West Seattle traffic will be disrupted for 6-8 years.  Fauntleroy Way SW, 35th Avenue SW, and SW Avalon Way will all be impacted.  It will be much worse than when the WS bridge broke.

8.     Sound Transit plans to bulldoze 3 acres of Pigeon Point disturbing the federally protected Heron rookery that houses 24 nests.

9.    WSLE light rail will travel over Longfellow Creek, threatening the extinction of our newly recovering native salmon and three beaver dams.   

10.    West Seattle provides up to one-third of the region’s urban canopy.  The resulting heat zones will cause poorer neighborhoods to suffer disproportionately than the leafier areas, Delridge and Admiral.  (Seattle has lost more than 255 acres of forest canopy since 2016.  Sound Transit already cut 14,000 trees for the Everett-Tacoma spine.)

11. ST WSLE will be built on a known earthquake fault line. Their solution, we are told, is to drive the stanchions to a 100’ depth. Does this guarantee more stability?

What needs to be considered before the final EIS:

 1.The federally required NO BUILD OPTION that has not been studied.  

 2. Mitigation plans are vague or non-existent for the “damage” Sound Transit admits they will do to many ecosystems.   They used the words “permanent” and “irreparable” in the DEIS.  Who oversees this mitigation?  Is there an agency we can appeal to BEFORE the damage happens?

3. Why are we spending $4 billion, creating 614,000 tons of carbon emissions for 4 miles of track that will take us only to SODO? 

4. Ridership numbers need to be reviewed, considering the number of people working from home.

5A Town Hall. West Seattle has repeatedly asked for—and not received—a voice in our future. Sound Transit’s meager outreach to our community is at the Sunday Market and station design events. We deserve to be given clear details about your project, which will greatly inform our lives.  

West Seattle has many “components that require further study” – until these are addressed, we deserve to be kept in the Draft EIS process.  The Ballard community was successful in its attempt not to be pushed into the final EIS.

We heard at the Board of Directors meeting on March 28, 2024, that instead of the mid-2024 projected final EIS date for West Seattle, it will now be “late spring” 2024.  We have still not been told what the exact route is!  Sound Transit has been surveying, drilling, and mapping utilities and the trees they plan to cut in the neighborhoods they plan to destroy.  They have gone door-to-door, asking people to sign two-year Right of Entry Agreements.  They have also canvassed homes and businesses along their, yet to be determined, route urging people to sign Early Property Acquisition Agreements.  We believe this to be illegal.  Bruce Dammeier pointed out at the B of D meeting that this is unprecedented.  But the board passed the measure.  They did not call the roll.  Many members had been on their cell phones during much of the meeting; one even left during the public comments, but they managed to croak out a “yea” to pass Resolution No R2024-07.   This needless destruction, deforestation, displacement, and disruption is action will cause will impact the entire region. But we have no recourse, no voice.  Once we are declared to be in the final EIS we are doomed.  We urgently need help.  We have thoughtful solutions.  Our only hope is to be kept in the DEIS process until our concerns are addressed and we are allowed a seat at the table.

Paul Thompson, Chair, Community Oversight Panel

Sound Transit Board Meeting, March 28, 2024

Re: Delivery of Service Quality to the Voters in the ST3 System Plan: 

 "In the context of evaluation of the project alternatives during the planning and environmental review process, the COP often asks staff for assurance that alternatives under consideration would achieve the goals of the System Plans and explanations of how they would do so.  In the case of some alternatives introduced in the past year, particularly on the West Seattle and Ballard Link Extensions, staff have been unable to provide such assurance. This will be a matter of ongoing concern to the COP in coming years."

Video by Pamela Adams Wildlife Technician March 29, 2024

Robert Ho photographer Courtesy of Bird Note.org

Sound Transit plans to bulldoze 3 acres of Pigeon Point disturbing the federally protected Heron rookery that houses 24 nests.

The Seattle Times, Traffic Lab March 29, 2024 at 6:00 am

Terri Mestas joins Sound Transit as deputy CEO for megaproject delivery. (Courtesy Sound Transit)

“At the same Sound Transit meeting where Mestas was introduced, the Board of Directors voted to approve Resolution No R 2024-07. This resolution will allow Sound Transit to go ahead with Early Property Acquisitions for the West Seattle Link Extension BEFORE they even declare a final route! This is not legal. Bruce Dammeier pointed out that issuing Early Property Acquisitions before the route is finalized is unprecedented, but the motion passed. The committee noted that property values are going up; and as Constantine has said, on the record, early property acquisitions are like money in the bank. Sound Transit has been drilling, surveying, and mapping utilities and the trees they plan to cut for over two years. at the same time, West Seattle businesses, residents, and the community have been held in a cruel limbo. We taxpayers have no say in our future. We are given, at most, two minutes to plead our case to the board or committee. There is no acknowledgement, no "thanks for commenting", and no discussion. Many members are on their cell phones during the comment period. And we have no recourse! We have repeatedly asked Sound Transit to hold a real town hall to address our many questions. The West Seattle light rail link will cost almost $4 BILLION for 4 miles of track that will take us only to SODO IN TEN YEARS! Some 70 West Seattle Businesses will be "taken" for this project, causing 500 people to lose their jobs. And now - we are told that the final EIS is coming "late spring" - sooner than we were told. Once Sound Transit "finalizes" the route, we will have exactly 30 days to comment. UNSOUND TRANSIT - Destroying Communities They Pretend to Serve. But they are accountable to no one.” rethinkthelink.org

Alki Beach Academy, Delridge Deli Mart, Sound Physical Therapy, Subway, Pacific Northwest Theatre Associates, Uptown Espresso are all going to be demolished.

We can ask board to keep West Seattle in the draft EIS process until they review our “components that require further study” - Ballard was able to do this because enough people spoke out.

This means that there are better alternatives. Other transportation improvements will continue.

info@skylarkcafe.com

West Seattle has a Transit Desert.

Sound Transit’s NO BUILD OPTION can improve all our modes* of community transit.

*Rapid Ride/Frequent, Washington State Ferries, Water Taxi, Dart, Access, VanPool.

Transit deserts lack adequate public transit. These areas contain populations that are transit-dependent.

WEST SEATTLE LIGHT RAIL IS OVER BUDGET. IT WILL COST $4 BILLION.

SOUND TRANSIT COULD BETTER SPEND THAT MONEY ON OUR BUSES - AND OTHER EXISTING TRANSIT.

HERE ARE MORE REASONS WHY WE WANT SOUND TRANSIT TO STUDY THE NO BUILD OPTION.

Images are downloadable on our Artwork page!

Read thoughtful conversations from:

The Good News

In Sound Transit’s Draft Environmental Impact Statement (DEIS) there is a federally required No Build Alternative. No Build does not mean "do nothing." It does mean maintaining and continuing to improve what we have.

“The No Build Alternative includes projects, funding packages, and proposals in the central Puget Sound region planned to occur with or without the WSBLE. No Build improvements include transit, roadway, and other transportation actions by state, regional, and local agencies currently funded or committed, and those likely to be implemented based on approved and committed funding.”

Rethinkthelink.org strongly urges Sound Transit to seriously examine its NO BUILD OPTION.

We THINK We Walked The Route!

September 17, 2023

But . . . Sound Transit still won’t tell us. So we studied the available material and made an educated guess.